Wednesday, November 16, 2011

Arkham City: Rocksteady's Audition for Spiderman

Let me start off by saying Batman: Arkham City is a great game. I would give it a solid recommendation to anyone who is a fan of any of the following: Batman, stealth games, open-world games, games with an enthralling narrative. It's very well crafted (especially when held up against some other recent new releases) and it keeps me so engaged that I find it difficult to put down the controller.

Arkham City featured an open world that is a perfect playground for Batman. It's a large, sectioned-off slum of Gotham City, plagued with gang warfare, used to house Gotham's criminally insane, since Arkham Asylum and Blackgate Penitentiary was deemed no longer fit for use. This provides the ideal setting for Batman to stalk the scum of Gotham City and to make him the predator of the night that he truly is. But the best part is that it does this without suffering the same mistake that most other open-world games make, and that is sacrificing detail for sheer scope. Every square inch of Arkham City has the personality you'd expect from a rundown Gotham City, once inhabited by the poor, now overtaken by criminals. The interiors look unique, per location, and I never got the sense of any room being a copy/paste of any other room.

The combat system is refined and robust and truly captures the feeling of taking on multiple thugs as the Dark Knight. If you're as big of a comic book nerd as I am, you'd know that Batman is a master martial artist and dispatch any number of unarmed thugs with relative ease. The combat system really captures that feel, all with its own relative ease. It's a simple 4 button layout: attack, block, dodge, and counter, so combat flows smoothly and effortlessly.

But most importantly, Rocksteady took a beloved universe and added an original spin on it while staying true to the source material. Arkham City (and Arkham Asylum) is an enjoyable and authentic Batman experience. My only gripe is the casting of Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill to voice Batman and the Joker respectively. They're both very talented, but that choice kind of gave this project a touch of Batman: The Animated Series instead of making it 100% original. But that's a minor complaint.

And as I sat there playing, I thought to myself: swinging around a large open city, fast paced acrobatic combat, and a faitful comic book-to-video game adaptation? This would be perfect for Spiderman! There are so many elements in Arkham City that can be translated to a Spiderman video game. If download Catwoman's missions, you even get a taste of wall-crawling (just like a real cat).

Over the years, many Spiderman games have been published, but by far the best has been Spiderman 2 (2004), based on the movie that was released that summer. Games based on movies usually get a bad rap (and most of them deserve it) but this game was a major exception. This was the first Spiderman game that put you in Spidey's shoes in a fully recreated New York City to web-sling around. And that's what you need in a Spiderman game: lots of open area (in New York) and the ability to just swing around. To further enhance the experience, citizens on the street will notice you. Some will cheer you, others will boo you, and some will cry for help (which will start a mini-mission, anything from stopping a high speed car chase to helping a child recover their lost balloon), which you can ignore. The combat isn't great, but it's fluid and fast paced and it mimics how Spidey would fight, so it's generally fun. The plot doesn't feel too restricting, even though it follows the movie's plot, but there are a couple side stories involving other members of Spidey's rogues gallery, such as Mysterio and Rhino. So it works out well, given what it was working with.

So my question is, why can't we use the things that Arkham City have taught us to recreate the magic from Spiderman 2? All of the ingredients are there, it's just a matter of execution. Sure, there will be some additions and subtractions, mainly the lack of predator and detective elements as well as Batman's arsenal of gadgets, but I think this opens up some doors to be creative. Maybe more environment based combat? Or some epic, fast-paced aerial boss battles?

I think that Rocksteady can really get creative with this concept. Spiderman hasn't been represented by a good game in a long while, and I think they can do him justice.

Monday, November 7, 2011

In the Beginning, there were many...

I've been gaming my whole damn life. My first game was Pole Position II for Atari 7800 and I was terrible at it. Despite my relative suckiness, somehow my 4 year old eyes perceived the sounds and flashing lights as excellence. But it was the sounds and flashing lights that kept me coming back for more, even way after the days of the Atari 7800.

As I grew, so did the video game industry and so did technology. Two-button joy-pads made way for analog sticks which in turn made way for motion controls. The pixelated battle between Pac-man and the ghosts took back seat to the high definition war between various noble armies and any combination of either Nazis, Russians or aliens. Nintendo went from being a hardcore gaming juggernaut to making family friendly games at the expense of adopting the latest technology, and Sega has been reduced to making the same Sonic the Hedgehog game for a decade after they got out of the console game. And here I've been, watching the whole thing unfold like a drama of complete nerd-dom.

Let me make one thing clear: I am not opposed to change, especially this one in the video game industry. All change has its good and its bad. The thing about change in the video game industry (namely improving hardware) is that developers tend to get sidetracked with making stellar graphics and cinematics and focus less on what makes a game a game: gameplay. The progression of technology was intended to spur innovation, but in some ways it has stifled it.

To illustrate what I mean, here is an example:

The original Mortal Kombat (1992) was created by a team of FOUR developers under one year. Not only was it one of the most popular arcade games of all time, but it also served as a major template for the way fighting games would be made from then on AND set a precedence for video game violence which would permeate throughout video games from then on. It made violence acceptable (provided you're not some crazy person that doesn't know the difference between fantasy and reality) and allowed developers of today to create those hardcore action titles that we've all grown to love.

Jump ahead 16 years, and you'll see Grand Theft Auto 4 (2008): a critically acclaimed game with stunning visuals and a bustling, lifelike city with NPCs that behave realistically so that you can... take your cousin out to dinner, watch a digitized version of Katt Williams perform stand-up comedy and drive around cars that behave like shopping carts that had their wheels removed.

Here's the bottom line: despite some gems and some other complete works of art, the game industry has become convoluted. As a friend of mine told me, we are now in an age of rehashing instead of an age of innovation. And equally convoluted has become the video games media industry. Far too often are good games overlooked in preference to popular franchises, smaller developers with fewer resources get shat on, and bias and inconsistent coverage has created fanboyism amongst its readers.

So even though I am just one man with many opinions, this will be my forum to tell the video games community just exactly how I feel. It may not be popular and it probably won't be what other people think, but it will have some sense of authenticity that other outlets, I believe, lack. I hope you enjoy it.